Can't create revision/resubmission - revision/resubmission already started

The submission fails with ScholarOne error code 18.

Why it happens…

The chain of events is typically:

  1. The author submits successfully through Author Portal (true original or in-flight revision)
  2. Peer review
  3. Revision requested
  4. Author submits revision through S1M or starts a draft (root cause)
  5. Author submits revision (again) through Author Portal
  6. Author Portal export to S1M fails

To resolve:

  1. Proxy as the author in S1M and delete the duplicate revision.
  2. Open Author Portal and end the user proxy session. Then select Submissions > Actions > Resubmit.
  3. Wait at least 15 minutes, then verify that the status of the submission is no longer Failed in Author Portal.